Compared to Whom?
Kerby Anderson
“To know only one country is to know none.” That insight by Seymour Martin Lipset is so important that Jonah Goldberg believes it should be pounded into the heads of every high school student. He suggests that: “Whenever you hear people talk about America as uniquely or exceptionally flawed—or superior—the first question you should ask is, “compared to whom?” He provides several examples.
Yes, America has a murder problem. But it is worth putting that tragedy in perspective. Do you know where America ranks internationally on homicides? The number is 64. That shouldn’t keep us from wanting to make this country safer. But when we hear about how bad a social or political problem in this country is, we should also ask the question, compared to whom?
The title of his article is “The Race to Racism.” The charge of racism is thrown around so much that it is likely that many Americans believe that this country is the most racist country in the world. Some may even believe that we are the only racist country in the world. That is why the statement by Seymour Martin Lipset is so important.
International surveys have asked people in different countries if they would have a problem with a person of a different race as a neighbor. “Three percent of Americans say they’d object to racially different neighbors. That makes us half as racist as Finland, roughly a quarter as racist as Spain and Italy, and slightly less racist than Germany or France.”
The US isn’t the most tolerant country in the world, but many of these other European countries have even more work to do. I think those percentages are something to keep in mind the next time you hear someone say the US needs to be more like Europe.
Listen to this Viewpoint
Viewpoints
View All
Case For America
As we celebrate 250 years of America, there is a need to make the case once again for this country.
High and Low
If you look at the American economy, you see a high and a low. The stock market is at a record high, while consumer sentiment is at the lowest ever measured.
Take Action
View All
Support the Safeguarding Women from Chemical Abortion Act
The abortion pill harms women and kills unborn children. Congress must act.
Contact Congress About the Prevent Government Shutdowns Act of 2025
Congress needs to get the job done, not run away from work.