VIEW VIEWPOINT

Alito's Question

Written by Kerby Anderson June 5 - 2015
The top lawyer for the U.S. government had to answer a question he probably would have preferred not to tackle during oral arguments before the U.S. Supreme Court in Obergefell vs. Hodges, the marriage case. Justice Samuel Alito asked the Obama Administration’s Solicitor General, Donald Verrilli a question about how the religious liberty of religious schools that oppose same-sex marriage might be affected if the Court rules that same-sex marriage is a civil right. Justice Alito brought up a case that came before the court in 1983, Bob Jones University vs. United States. Here’s the exchange: Justice Alito asked: “in the Bob Jones case, the Court held that a college was not entitled to tax exempt status if it opposed interracial marriage or interracial dating. So would the same apply to a university or a college if it opposed same sex marriage?” Mr. Verrilli, the Solicitor General replied: “You know, I…I don’t think I can answer that question without knowing more specifics, but it’s certainly going to be an issue. I…I don’t deny that, Justice Alito. It is…it is going to be an issue.” (bolding mine) For an organization’s tax exempt status to be revoked means it would no longer be exempt from federal income tax and is not eligible to receive tax-deductible contributions. Many, probably most schools would not survive that. General Verrilli’s answer was: yes, religious schools that oppose same sex marriage in their policies and teachings will have their tax-exempt status challenged and be likely to lose it if same sex marriage becomes the law of the land. What about other organizations that hold to orthodox Christian beliefs? Like churches? Will churches be subject to loss of tax exempt status if every state is forced to perform, or even recognize, same sex marriages? Another Justice, Antonin Scalia, asked during oral arguments, “Is it conceivable that a minister who is authorized by the state to conduct marriage can decline to marry two men if indeed this court holds that they have a constitutional right to marry?” Then he said, “I don’t see how.” Kelly Shackelford of Liberty Institute says, if we get a bad ruling later this month, religious liberty will come under severe attack. It’s begun with wedding vendors. Other faith-based businesses will have hiring practices and rights to operate according to their religious beliefs challenged. Christian colleges’ and schools’ accreditation will come under fire. Governments will attempt to force faith-based adoption and foster care providers to place children with homosexual couples. Licensing for many professions will depend upon acceptance of the gay agenda. And employees at every level of government and in the military, as well as federal contractors will be penalized or punished if they do not toe the line that the right to same-sex marriage trumps religious liberty. When it comes to religious liberty, one of America’s first founding principles, we’re at a tipping point. viewpoints_horizontal_penna

Listen to this Viewpoint

Viewpoints

View All
1792436339 6ad668737c9c3
October 20, 2026
Kerby Anderson

Lynching

Wilfred Reilly has spent years exposing false narratives about racism and racist actions. In his latest article, he explains “What Happens When the Demand for Racism Exceeds Supply?". He makes the sam...

Listen
1792389289 6ad5b0a95f457
October 19, 2026
Kerby Anderson

Lack of Affordability

The 2026 election was about many issues, but a significant one was the lack of affordability. Unfortunately, few politicians want to admit that the real reason is the declining value of the dollar. Po...

Listen
1792042831 6ad0674fdc19c
October 16, 2026
Penna Dexter

Place For Prayer

Some people might wonder why we need a law that protects the right of houses of worship to use their facilities for religious purposes. But we do. And we have one: RLUIPA, the Religious Land Use and I...

Listen

Take Action

View All
Protect Privacy Against Flock Cameras
August 9, 2026

Protect Privacy Against Flock Cameras

Flock cameras are everywhere. While one camera is a tool, the more than 100,000 AI-powered cameras now posted around our nation are a new layer of dig...

Support the SAVE Act
July 20, 2026

Support the SAVE Act

SAVE Election Integrity with Voter ID.

Support the Safeguarding Women from Chemical Abortion Act
April 15, 2026

Support the Safeguarding Women from Chemical Abortion Act

The abortion pill harms women and kills unborn children. Congress must act.

FACE Act Repeal Act of 2025
January 12, 2026

FACE Act Repeal Act of 2025

Pro-lifers have been abused under the FACE Act for long enough.